WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Howard Lutnick asked Pure Lithium to give Washington a 51% controlling stake tied to a proposed manufacturing plant.
- Pure Lithium rejected the proposal, warning it could invite scrutiny and cripple future capital raising or an IPO.
- The company would operate but not own the plant, while receiving no direct funding under the proposed arrangement.
- The Commerce Department rejected Pure Lithium’s counterproposal offering the government a 9.9% stake.
DISCLAIMER: GoldInvestors.news is not a registered investment, legal or tax advisor or broker/dealer. All investment/financial opinions expressed by GoldInvestors.news are from the personal research and experience of the owner of the site and are intended as educational material. Although best efforts are made to ensure that all information is accurate and up to date, occasionally unintended errors and misprints may occur.
US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick asked battery startup Pure Lithium in July to surrender a 51% controlling stake to Washington in exchange for support tied to a proposed manufacturing plant, according to documents reviewed by Reuters and a person with direct knowledge of the request.
Under the proposal, Pure Lithium would neither own nor control the plant. The privately held company rejected the arrangement, warning that majority federal ownership could invite public scrutiny, damage its ability to raise capital and outweigh any benefit to shareholders.
“51% is far outside precedent and invites scrutiny,” Pure Lithium’s legal counsel Skadden Arps wrote in an August 22 memorandum outlining Lutnick’s request. The unsuccessful federal effort to obtain majority control of Pure Lithium had not previously been reported.
Reuters based its account on documents that included emails between Pure Lithium and the Commerce Department about a meeting involving Lutnick and Pure Lithium CEO Emilie Bodoin. The records also included the memorandum from the company’s attorneys describing the government’s request.
The proposal was another attempt by the Trump administration to acquire an ownership position in an American company. Since Donald Trump returned to the White House, the administration has taken stakes in several businesses, including chipmaker Intel, extending federal involvement in the private sector beyond that of recent administrations.
The administration has not acquired a majority stake in a company. Its most serious attempt involved a proposed rescue of Spirit Airlines, while its largest agreed equity position would provide a 15% stake in rare earths company MP Materials and make the government its largest shareholder.
A Pure Lithium representative did not dispute the account when asked about the proposal. The Commerce Department did not respond to questions from Reuters, while the White House also did not answer requests for comment.
Federal acquisition of equity in a private company is not illegal, and the administration has defended such transactions, particularly when using money stemming from the 2022 CHIPS Act. Lawmakers opposed to the practice argue that the law, designed to strengthen domestic semiconductor research and manufacturing, never authorized government ownership, though no court has ruled on that question.
Pure Lithium has developed a lithium metal battery that it says is considerably more efficient than a traditional lithium-ion battery and can be manufactured without graphite, nickel or cobalt. Analysts have said successful mass production could change how the US military and other federal contractors power millions of devices.
Lutnick met with Bodoin in Washington on July 29 for roughly 45 minutes. According to the documents and the person familiar with the meeting, Lutnick expressed interest in the battery’s efficiency and capabilities and said federal control was necessary so the technology could be used by the US military and other agencies.
The meeting was initially arranged to discuss Pure Lithium’s legal dispute with Japan’s Panasonic over the battery technology. Billionaire Robert Friedland, one of Pure Lithium’s largest shareholders, arranged the meeting and attended alongside Commerce Department senior adviser David Shapiro.
Friedland cofounded I-Pulse, which received $250 million from the Commerce Department in June. Through a spokesperson, Friedland declined to comment, and Reuters found no evidence that Lutnick personally owns a stake in I-Pulse or Pure Lithium.
Lutnick also suggested the takeover could assist Pure Lithium in its Panasonic dispute, according to the person. Pure Lithium sued Panasonic in March, alleging that the Japanese company reverse engineered its lithium metal battery technology, a claim Panasonic disputes, with a January hearing scheduled on Pure Lithium’s request for a preliminary injunction.
In exchange for the government’s majority stake, Lutnick said $1 billion from Japan’s investment pledge would be reserved to construct a plant owned by an investment vehicle controlled by Tokyo and Washington. Pure Lithium would operate the facility without owning it and receive part of its revenue after debt servicing costs were paid.
The company itself would receive no direct funding under the proposal, according to the documents. Lutnick also asked Pure Lithium to provide 100 batteries to the Energy and Defense departments for testing, but the company rejected those requests and offered Washington a 9.9% stake instead.
The Commerce Department rejected that counterproposal in August. “Commerce remains fixed on 51% equity in Pure Lithium,” the August 22 memorandum said, adding that the department “is prepared to move on to other projects if Pure Lithium does not meet the mark.”
Pure Lithium’s attorneys warned the arrangement would “cripple Pure Lithium's ability to raise capital or pursue an IPO,” particularly because the company would lack control of the proposed plant. Lutnick has meanwhile expanded Commerce Department investments in the minerals sector, including stakes in USA Rare Earth and Korea Zinc.
DISCLAIMER: GoldInvestors.news is not a registered investment, legal or tax advisor or broker/dealer. All investment/financial opinions expressed by GoldInvestors.news are from the personal research and experience of the owner of the site and are intended as educational material. Although best efforts are made to ensure that all information is accurate and up to date, occasionally unintended errors and misprints may occur.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.